Endorsements
It is important to know that a transfer of taxes to land values
has been widely endorsed by well-known authorities in various fields
of endeavor. If the proposal produces so many real benefits,
well-known thinkers will surely know about it.
522 endorsements of land value taxation from well-known authorities
have already been published in the pages of Incentive Taxation
(3,000 estimated circulation, established in 1974) an eight-times-yearly
newsletter devoted to objective news about land assessment taxation.
We have another five hundred or so such endorsements in our files.
We print below the names and description of some of these endorsers.
Note particularly the eight recent American winners of the Nobel
Prize in economics who have endorsed this tax reform; they are Milton
Friedman, Herbert Simon, Paul Samuelson, James Tobin, James Buchanan,
Franco Modigliani, Robert Solow, and William Vickrey.
The actual words of these Nobel Prize winners are listed in the
November 1991 issue of Incentive Taxation (at that time,
William Vickrey was the president-elect of the American Economics
Association, but he later won the Nobel Prize).
See each issue of Incentive Taxation for the direct quotations
from these endorsers:
City/County Officials
- Newton D. Baker (mayor of Cleveland), Joseph Barr (former
mayor of Pittsburgh), Russell Conklin (former mayor, Gt. Falls),
James Clarkson (former mayor, Southfield MI), Tom L. Johnson (former
mayor of Cleveland), report of 13 rural municipal or county councils
in Australia, Allentown, Pa. city council study, Councilman Gavan
Oakley (former v.p. Aus. Muni. Assn.), Ken Synett (former mayor,
Marion, Aus.), Sydney Aus. city council (1966 report), Michael Albert
(former Douglas County Board Chairman, Neb.), Ralph Perk (former
mayor, Cleveland), W. Magee (former Pittsburgh mayor), John McCulloch,
(former Chief Assessor, Johannesburg), Councilman Bennett Rodgers
(Pittsburgh), Wilmington City Council (1969 study).
Philosophers &
Historical Figures - Mortimer Adler, Robt. Andelson (Professor
of Philosophy, Auburn University), Charles A. Beard (historian),
Louis D. Brandeis (Supreme Court Justice), Nicholas Murray Butler
(former President, Columbia University), Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman
and Herbert Asquith (former British Prime Ministers), Winston Churchill,
FDR, Eisenhower, John Dewey (philosopher), Paul Douglas (former
U.S. Senator from Illinois), Wm. Cobden (19c. free-trade reformer),
Ecclesiastes v. 4, Albert Einstein, Fortune Magazine, U.S.
GAO, Walter Heller (former chairman, U.S. Council of Econ. Advisers),
Ebenezer Howard (father of the garden city movement), Alduous Huxley,
Helen Keller, John Kieran (one-time N.Y. Times columnist),
Abraham Lincoln, Leviticus XXV, John Stuart Mill, Ralph Nader, Rep.
Henry Reuss, Judge Samuel Seabury, Herbert Spencer, Sun Yat Sen,
Leo Tolstoi, Dorothy Thompson, Wall Street Journal (3/19/69,
8/21/72, 3/12/85, etc.), Woodrow Wilson, Cecil B. DeMille, Amer.
Inst. of Economic Research, Milwaukee Sentinel (2/4/67),
N.Y. Times (7 editorials, 1980s), Thos. Jefferson (1785),
David Lawrence (former Pa. governor), Theodore Roosevelt, Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette.
Others - Albert
Fondy (President, Pbg. Teachers, Union - AFL-CIO), Professor Mason
Gaffney (agricultural economist), Raymond Moley (former economics
professor, Columbia University), Business Week ("The Coming
Change in the Property Tax"), Harold S. Buttenheim (former editor
of the American City Magazine), Andrew Heiskell (former co-chairman,
Urban Coalition), John M. Kelly (Scranton, Pa. realtor), Liberal
Party (U.K.), Wm. Wilcox (former Secretary, Pa. D.C.A.).
Urbanologists -
Ray Archer (Asst. Secy, U.S. Dept. of Environment in H.U.D.), John
Due (M.I.T., African tax expert), H.W. Eastwood (former Chief Assessor,
New South Wales, Aus.), Professor (Columbia) Lowell Harriss (1973
president, Natl. Tax Assn.), Albert Hydeman, Jr. (former Secretary,
Pa. Dept. of Community Affairs), Intl. Union of Local Authorities
(1974 report), Labor (1973 issue), Local Govt. Assn. (Aus.),
Carl Madden (former Chief Economist, U.S. Chamber of Commerce),
H.L.J. May (Minister of Local Govt., N.Z.), New South Wales Royal
Commission on Local Govt. Finance & Valuation, 1967 report),
NYC Special Planning Commission - 1964 report), Pa. State Planning
Commission - 1978 report), E.R.A. Seligman (19 c. Columbia professor),
Donald Stone (former professor, Carnegie-Mellon University), Karl
Falk (past pres., NAHRO), Tax Foundation (10/76 report), Lester
Thurow (econ. prof. M.I.T.), U.K. Land Institute Study of Whitsable,
U.N. Habitat Conference (1976), U.S. Congressional Research Svce.,
Urban Land Institute (Research Monograph #12, also #19), Robert
C. Wood (former President, Univ. of Mass, former H.U.D. Secy.),
A. M. Woodruff (former president, U. of Hartford and real-estate
appraiser), Colin Clark (former economics professor, Oxford University),
Brevard Crihfield (former Ex. Dir., Council of State Governments),
Tom Curtis (former Chairman, Joint Economic Committee of Congress),
Richard Doyle (former Indiana state representative). Financial
World, Harper's Magazine (May 1968), Dean Gillies (once director
of U.C.L.A.'s Real Estate Research Program), Michigan (1976 report),
Ted Gwartney (real-estate assessor), James Heilbrun (real-estate
tax authority, Robt. Hutchins (former professor, U. of Chicago),
R.W. Hewison (Toronto study), Dan. Holland (former M.I.T. prof.
of finance), House & Home magazine (Aug. 1960), Arthur D. Little
Co. (urban consultants), Modesto CA Chamber of Commerce, Edmund
Muskie (former U.S. senator), N.A.R.E.B., 1974 or 1975), Nat. Comm.
On Urban Problems, Dick Netzer (N.Y.U. professor, also Brookings
Institution), New Republic (1/27/93), official Aus. study (5/73),
Omaha study (1970s), Frank Othick (U.K. Land Institute study), Pa.
Bur. of Muni. Affairs, Practical Builder, Kaiser Committee
report, Quebec report (1976), Raymond Saulnier (former Chrmn., Council
of Econ. Advisers), Roy Stauffer (Pa. Chamber of Commerce),
Time Magazine (5/71), Royal Commission (U.K.), Pa. Economy League
(1996).
Environmentalists
- Louis Bromfield (author), Farm Foundation (1979 report),
D.C. Environmental Committee, (1999), David Brunori (1998 study),
Md. Sierra Club (study), 1001 Friends of Md., Center for Policy
Alternatives, Minnesota Environmental Defense Fund, Sierra Club
(New Columbia Chapter), Sprawl Watch Clearinghouse, U/Md. School
of Law, Rachel's Environmental & Health Weekly, Canadian
Inst. for Environmental Law & Policy, Toward a Sustainable Chesapeake.
So many well-known endorsers - why didn't they bring about land
value taxation in the United States? Primarily because it wasn't
their chief reform issue and they didn't know how to implement a
land-assessment tax in the foreseeable future.
This partial yet extensive list reproduced here does show that
land- assessment taxation has been looked upon favorably by many
experts and well-known people. Because of space limitations,
we mentioned here just 120 of them. We didn't include all
the endorsers we know about, especially the more recent ones, and
there surely are others we don't know about.
*
We have been advised that we should reprint the actual words of
these endorsers, but space limitations preclude that. Instead,
we reprint just one representative quotation, this from the Urban
Land Institute research monograph #4, p. 28.
Referring to land value taxation, "Here surely is a golden
key to urban renewal, to the automatic regeneration of the city
- and not at public expense." Of course, counties,
school and other special districts, state and national governments
can do this also.
*
Reminder: feel free to order the report
containing 237 summaries of empirical studies on the effects of
land value taxation from all over the world, the U.S. included (cost
$12 postpaid). Or you could order the briefer report containing
only a representative 22 of these summaries (free, no obligation).
|